Criminalising justice

Herlambang P Wiratraman

“Honourable row of judges, once again, people’s lives, happiness, wealth and assent have been disrupted! The impact of a bullion mining activities in a Tumpang Pitu stable timberland area has caused genuine wretchedness to a internal community. we reject a cave given my life has been influenced by a dangers of mining. we am fighting for a stable timberland in a Tumpang Pitu towering area, confronting drop by a bullion mine”

Heri Budiawan

random post

Appeal session, Banyuwangi, 9 Jan 2018

Two decades after a commencement of reformasi, anti-communist view is still everywhere in Indonesia. Until today, ‘the spook of communism’, or of a PKI (Indonesian Communist Party), is invoked to overpower critique and even to politicise authorised issues. The purpose of a troops is still mostly seen as ‘saving a nation’ and as a mystic aegis of domestic stability.

A domestic dispute recently targeted a tellurian rights and environmental defender from Banyuwangi, famous as a morning city. There, in 2015, after a unsuccessful traffic to stop bullion mining in a region, internal communities started publicly protesting opposite a environmental drop caused by a mining operations. Subsequently, these internal communities were frequently intimidated by thugs, or privatised gangsters. Heri Budiawan – famous locally as Budi Pego – was one of a categorical protesters charged with comrade activities. Even yet he did not know what communism was about, he was indicted of being concerned in communist activities given he had carried a criticism ensign that featured a produce and sickle, like a pitch of a PKI, that has been a banned domestic celebration given 1966. Budi Pego pronounced he did not know who had embellished a trademark on a banner.

The justification collected by a troops enclosed a pickup lorry carrying 8 banners, and a peep hoop containing a video of a transformation available by Sidik Bintoro, a Banyuwangi 1 TV journalist. Based on this justification Budi Pego was indicted of swelling a thought of communism, a crack of Article 107a of a Criminal Code, famous as a Communist Article. Since deliberating communism is still banned in post-1965 Indonesia, a indictment of communism is a really grave one and invoking this essay has turn an easy approach to dispute vicious voices in society.

Initially, a Public Prosecutor (JPU) demanded seven years in prison for Budi Pego. After his detain in Sep 2017, he was sent to a Banyuwangi Class IIB Correctional Institution, where he was kept in apprehension for 5 and a half months. Judges finally condemned him for swelling comrade promotion during strikes, on comment of a banner. The row of judges resolved that Budi knew there were banners around temperament a produce and sickle trademark and he did not try to stop this. Throughout a trial, a banners in doubt were never seen.

Outside a courtroom, a indictment of communism was serve reinforced by a organization named Gerakan Anti-Kebangkitan Komunis, or GAKK (Movement Against a Rise of Communism). During a hearing protesters with posters called out ‘Beware of a arise of PKI’ and ‘PKI is a rivalry of a state and a people!’

A organization of academics in Surabaya, however, has criticised a judges’ decision, saying that it was formed on diseased or even misleading authorised reasoning. They argued that most remained unproven, including that a produce and sickle on a ensign over a authorised criteria for ‘teaching or swelling communism’. Doing so would embody seeking to ‘overthrow a legitimate government’, that a organization says a contribution of a box do not advise Budi was doing.

Budi Pego’s box has been taken adult by tellurian rights groups during home and abroad / Kontras

The spook of communism

Communism has been a banned beliefs in Indonesia given a 1966 MPR (People’s Consultative Assembly) direct on a retraction of a PKI. The bid of a spook of communism instils low stress in vast tools of Indonesian multitude to this day and therefore stays a absolute tool. In a box of Budi Pego, those in energy invoked communism to overpower protesters and change courtesy divided from environmental issues.

Regardless of a domestic stigma, a justice has unsuccessful in a insurance of tellurian rights, and unsuccessful to strengthen a defenders of environmental rights, who are due insurance underneath Indonesian law No.32/2009 wherein Article 66 stipulates that ‘every chairman who fights for a right to a good and healthy sourroundings can't be prosecuted with a rapist assign or polite suit’. It is so transparent that this authorised preference has failed to protect a inherent rights of a citizen according to Indonesian law.

A poignant case

The probable effects of this preference are worrisome. Most importantly, a support of this leveraging of a comrade tarnish will make people fearful to criticize injustices finished to their communities. There are 3 serve reasons that make this box generally poignant for Indonesia’s authorised story as good as for assessing a stream growth of tellurian rights in Indonesia.

Firstly, it was a initial time that a stigmatisation of an ideology, in this box communism, has been used to assistance request rapist charges underneath a newly revised Indonesian Penal Code of 1999. Previously, adults have instead been stigmatised as communists but due routine of law, that has infrequently resulted in non-judicial killings, kidnapping, seizure and assault and – in a box of 1965 killings – mass slaughter. What Budi’s box shows is how a law itself can be deployed as a apparatus for criminalising people, even in Indonesia’s approved system.

Secondly, in 2015, a boss of a mining association that Budi Pego protested opposite was AM Hendropriyono, a former BIN (Indonesia State Intelligence Agency) commander with a indeterminate tellurian rights record. Currently, Hendropriyono’s son is on a board. This reveals a corporate and troops energy dynamics that could get caught with tellurian rights cases.

Thirdly, a area where Budi Pego’s occurrence took place is historically significant. Banyuwangi has traditionally been home to some-more Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) supporters than those of other Muslim groups. NU, as an Islamic organisation, had been concerned in aroused dispute with a PKI. Severe assault took place in Banyuwangi during a mass murders of 1965-66. In further to those events, Banyuwangi also saw mass assault during a early years after Suharto stepped down, including a ‘dukun santet’ (sorcerer) cases and a 1998 East Java ninja scare. During a latter, puzzling ninjas were blamed for a array of killings of eremite teachers, Islamic boarding propagandize leaders, and people with mental illnesses.

Every year, girl and other residents of Banyuwangi, including a Ansor Youth Movement, remember ‘the ferocity of a PKI’ with a rite during a Pancasila Jaya Monument, circuitously Lubang Buaya (crocodile hole) in Cluring, Banyuwangi. The content on a Pancasila Jaya Monument reads: ‘Here on 18-10-1965 there was a mass murder of 62 Pancasila Youth members by a force of a G30S and a PKI’.

The modern-day politicisation of communism continues what started with a assault in 1965. The spook of a PKI did not disappear with a fall of a New Order. Instead, we are witnessing a lapse in a courtroom. Budi Pego’s box reveals how a bequest of Suharto’s authoritarianism keeps inspiring amicable life and citizenship in Indonesia. In his case, a law has been used to instrumentalise a ‘communist stigma’ in sequence to dispute a tellurian rights transformation and environmental rights activism. The use of ‘communism’ as an indictment in justice is a pointer of a dangerous politicisation of a authorised system.

Herlambang P Wiratraman ( is a comparison techer during a Centre of Human Rights Law Studies, Faculty of Law, Airlangga University.

Inside Indonesia 138: Oct-Dec 2019

More banyuwangAi ...

  • Cops see red peril in BanyuwangiCops see red peril in Banyuwangi PREMIUM In a case reminiscent of the New Order era, four Banyuwangi residents involved in a protest movement against local mining activities have been charged with spreading communism. […]
  • Indonesian activist goes on trial for communismIndonesian activist goes on trial for communism An anti-mining activist has pleaded not guilty in an Indonesian court to charges of spreading communism, in a case that his supporters say is a cynical attempt to undermine his activism. […]
  • Indonesia: Hammer-and-Sickle Banner at Rally Leads to ArrestIndonesia: Hammer-and-Sickle Banner at Rally Leads to Arrest Indonesian environmental activists condemned the arrest this week of one of their own for allegedly displaying a banner displaying communist symbols during an anti-mining […]